Do Instagram and TikTok mean banks are less safe?
Skip to content
Watch Live
British Broadcasting Corporation
Home
News
Football 2026
Sport
Business
Technology
Health
Culture
Arts
Travel
Earth
Audio
Video
Live
Documentaries
Home
News
US & Canada
UK
UK Politics
England
N. Ireland
N. Ireland Politics
Scotland
Scotland Politics
Wales
Wales Politics
Africa
Asia
China
India
Australia
Europe
Latin America
Middle East
In Pictures
BBC InDepth
BBC Verify
Football 2026
Sport
Business
World of Business
Technology of Business
NYSE Opening Bell
Technology
Watch Documentaries
Artificial Intelligence
Intelligence Revolution
AI v the Mind
Tech Now
Health
Watch Documentaries
Culture
Watch Documentaries
Film & TV
Music
Art & Design
Style
Books
Entertainment News
Arts
Watch Documentaries
Arts in Motion
Travel
Watch Documentaries
Destinations
Africa
Antarctica
Asia
Australia and Pacific
Caribbean & Bermuda
Central America
Europe
Middle East
North America
South America
World’s Table
Culture & Experiences
Adventures
The SpeciaList
Earth
Watch Documentaries
Science
Natural Wonders
Climate Solutions
Sustainable Business
Green Living
Audio
Podcast Categories
Radio
Audio FAQs
Video
Watch Documentaries
BBC Maestro
Discover the World
Live
Live News
Live Sport
Documentaries
Site search
Home
News
Sport
Football 2026
Business
Technology
Health
Culture
Arts
Travel
Earth
Audio
Video
Live
Documentaries
Weather
Newsletters
Watch Live
Do Instagram and TikTok mean banks are less safe?
29 March 2023
Share
Save
Add as preferred on Google
Faisal IslamEconomics editor
Getty Images
In the original Mary Poppins film, the nine year old Michael Banks accidentally starts a bank run by demanding back his tuppence coin.
The dynamics had barely evolved when in 2007, Northern Rock saw runs outside its branches, heralding the start of the 2007-08 global financial crisis.
A year on, when Bradford & Bingley ran into trouble, the Bank of England had spotters outside the bank's branches but were relieved to see no such queues for the nation's TV cameras.
But the dynamics of bank runs appear to be evolving - and heading off such panics may be getting harder.
I have often pondered the following question: what would the 2007-08 financial crisis have been like in the current era of Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok?
That question may now be being inadvertently and not wholly positively answered by the current banking jitters.
Silicon Valley Bank saw the fastest bank run in US history according to the head of the US central bank, Jerome Powell. His vice chair Michael Barr told the US Senate yesterday that "social media saw a surge in talk about a run, and uninsured depositors acted quickly to flee", pulling their funds "at an extraordinary rate of $40bn (£32bn)in one day".
On the following day SVB anticipated "even greater outflows" and so "panic prevailed among SVB's remaining depositors".
These are utterly staggering sums. The contagion was cross-continental. The Bank of England told MPs on Monday that SVB UK, its British arm, had lost £3bn, or 30%, of its deposit base on the same day.
Governor Andrew Bailey earlier this week said: "One of the lessons that we have to take from Silicon Valley Bank, and it's not the only example, is in an age of social media, the speed at which runs can take place. And in an age of digital banking, the speed at which social media can be translated into loss. This is very different from the Northern Rock-style queue at the branch".
100m sprint
He pointed to looking at changing the regulations on bank safety to see if they "match to that sort of dynamic that's taking place".
The dynamic is a combination of instant internet banking and social media, meaning that a system built on credibility, faith, and trust are now inherently more fragile. Think about the leading lights in tech on WhatsApp groups or Slack, advising the companies they are invested in to withdraw all their cash.
"Bank run" doesn't quite capture it. SVB was more of an 100 metre world record Olympic bank sprint.
And while SVB had its own special dynamic, with depositors concentrated in one industry, and with most deposits not covered by normal saver protections, these concerns do apply more widely.
A search of "bank run" on key social media over the past two weeks revealed a wide range of figures advising people to withdraw their cash from similar institutions.
Some of this was wrapped up into distrust of mainstream "experts" versus trust in cryptocurrency. Part of the success of Bitcoin, and crypto in general, has been evangelical scepticism of normal banking. This is now a vocal and noticeable online community, which was not present during the 2008 financial crisis.
Getty Images
All of this has not been helped by communications difficulties over what is and is not covered by US deposit guarantees.
The bottom line is that it is reasonable to conclude that a low trust environment bred on social media has a material impact on the fragility of a system built on faith.
That in turn might require a regulatory response.
The head of the Bank of England's regulator, the Prudential Regulation Authority's Sam Woods, told MPs yesterday that it might have to change its assumption about how quickly deposits can flee a bank.
At the moment what is known as the Liquidity Coverage Ratio assumes that a bank might only lose 0-20% of its retail deposits or 20-40% of its corporate deposits over a period of one month.
A reminder: SVB UK lost 30% of its deposits in a single day.
The current regulation seems likely to be changed, but the flip side of that will mean that banks might not be able to lend as much into the economy.
Perhaps this is an overreaction to the very special case of SVB. It is a careful balancing act. Other jurisdictions are also pondering whether to increase the amount of deposits covered under protection schemes. It is a fair criticism, however, that it is unrealistic to imagine businesses can bank, and run payrolls, from dozens of bank accounts, designed to protect all their deposit balances.
The good news is that the UK regulatory system has performed well so far. SVB UK was obliged to turn into a subsidiary last year, and that meant it had the assets to be sold on intact to HSBC, without taxpayer funding.
But the way we calculate the safety of banks may change quickly as a result of this month's "Insta-run".
Is this a banking crisis - how worried should I be?
Bank on heightened alert for further banking risks
Failed lender Silicon Valley Bank bought by rival
Companies
US economy
Social media
UK economy
Banking
Related
China's Moonshot AI claims Kimi K3 can rival OpenAI and Anthropic
Who is the frontrunner to be the UK's next chancellor?
Chip giant TSMC pledges another $100bn to expand US production
More from the BBC
1 day ago
Is the fear of unintentionally going viral changing clubbing for Gen Z?
For some young clubbers, the fear is not dancing badly, it's becoming content.
1 day ago
1 day ago
16 World Cup viral moments - from Posh Spice's nonchalance to Haaland's bromance
We look at some of the most memorable scenes during the 2026 World Cup that set the internet alight.
1 day ago
2 days ago
Catfished student gets £10k after photos used for fake dating profiles
Elha Mai Weston posed as the teenager to strike up romantic conversations on social media.
2 days ago
3 days ago
Teenager's inquest to reopen after mum's campaign
Ellen Roome believes her son's death in 2022 was as the result of an online challenge gone wrong.
3 days ago
3 days ago
What's happening to the UK economy and how does it affect you?
The rate of UK economic growth affects things like pay increases and the amount of tax raised.
3 days ago
British Broadcasting Corporation
Home
News
Football 2026
Business
Technology
Health
Culture
Arts
Travel
Earth
Sport
Audio
Video
Live
Documentaries
Weather
BBC Shop
BritBox
BBC in other languages
The BBC is in multiple languagesRead the BBC In your own language
BBC News Brasil
BBC News Mundo (Spanish)
BBC News မြန်မာ (Burmese)
BBC News 中文 (Chinese)
BBC News Indonesia
BBC News 코리아 (Korean)
BBC News ไทย (Thai)
BBC News Tiếng Việt (Vietnamese)
BBC News Azərbaycanca (Azeri)
BBC News Magyarul (Hungarian)
BBC News Кыргыз Кызматы (Kyrgyz)
BBC News Polska (Polish)
BBC News România (Romanian)
BBC News Русская служба (Russian)
BBC News na srpskom (Serbian)
BBC News Україна (Ukrainian)
BBC News O'zbek (Uzbek)
BBC News عربي (Arabic)
BBC News فارسی (Persian)
BBC News Türkçe (Turkish)
BBC News বাংলা (Bengali)
BBC News دری (Dari)
BBC News ગુજરાતી (Gujarati)
BBC News हिन्दी (Hindi)
BBC News मराठी (Marathi)
BBC News नेपाली (Nepali)
BBC News සිංහල (Sinhala)
BBC News پښتو (Pashto)
BBC News ਪੰਜਾਬੀ (Punjabi)
BBC News Afaan Oromoo
BBC News አማርኛ (Amharic)
BBC News Afrique (French)
BBC News Hausa
BBC News Gaelic NAIDHEACHDAN
BBC News Ìgbò
BBC News Japanese 日本語
BBC News Gahuza
BBC News Pidgin
BBC News Somali
BBC News Swahili
BBC News தமிழ் (Tamil)
BBC News తెలుగు (Telugu)
BBC News ትግርኛ (Tigrinya)
BBC News اردو (Urdu)
BBC News Yorùbá
BBC News World Service
Follow BBC on:
Terms of Use
Subscription Terms
About the BBC
Privacy Policy
Cookies
Accessibility Help
Contact the BBC
Advertise with us
Do not share or sell my info
BBC.com Help & FAQs
Content Index
Set Preferred Source
Copyright 2026 BBC. All rights reserved. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.